A list with over 350 names appeared in the New York Times this week to protest the proposed plan by President Donald Trump to bring peace and stability to the Palestinian people in Gaza. The ad’s brief text reads: “Trump has called for the removal of all Palestinians from Gaza. Jewish people say NO to ethnic cleansing!” The undersigned are a list of actors, leftist pulpit rabbis and cantors, and others who happily signed their names to what essentially amounts to a suicide note for the Jewish people. 

The plan that they are protesting is the proposal to relocate Palestinian refugees out of a war zone and the rubble that will take a decade to rebuild. This will allow these people to rebuild their lives, a luxury afforded to nearly every other refugee from every other conflict. The signers of this ad are against this plan because it hurts their cause, not the Palestinian one.

If these 350 names were to be polled, nearly all would claim that the future of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict would be a “two-state solution.” This policy is both outdated and completely false, a relic of a bygone diplomatic era that is antithetical to the realities of a post-October 7 world.

The “two-state solution” is spoken today only by the malicious and the ignorant. Those who speak of it either want to see Israel destroyed or they know so little about the history of the region that they are repeating what they’ve been told by those who want to see Israel destroyed.

There can be no “two-state solution” when there is already a state called Israel. You are not creating “two-states,” you are granting enough concessions and legitimacy to a group of people that have spent over 60 years conducting terrorist operations so they can themselves declare a state. They will never do so because there are not enough concessions that can be given to that terrorist entity if the state of Israel exists at all. Concessions were offered, and rejected, many times in the 1990s and 2000s.

The proof is clearly there within Gaza, as the Palestinians living there were given a de facto state in 2005. Over 10,000 Jews were forcibly removed from Gaza, from land they bought and cultivated, to make room for that state. American Jewish businessmen raised money to buy agricultural equipment from those Jews to give to the Palestinian people so they can be self-sufficient in that state. Those people destroyed that equipment, elected Hamas to govern them, and launched an 18 year terror campaign against Israel.

Now, 16 months after they launched their most successful attack, Gaza is destroyed, their leadership dead, and the people there turned from fake “refugees” into actual refugees. The Palestinians in Gaza manage to break every definition of refugee that exists. First, they were the only refugees that had their own United Nations agency dedicated to them (UNRWA). They were also the only refugees that lived in cities for four generations. Now, they are the only refugees that cannot seek refuge anywhere.

After World War Two, Jewish refugees were placed in Displaced Persons (DP) camps while they resettled. Few returned back to their homes in Eastern Europe, they either fled West to America or East to help found Israel. During the Syrian Civil War, millions of refugees went to neighboring countries. Same with Ukrainians after Russia attacked. Population movement to neighboring countries is common for war refugees, and has never been called “ethnic cleansing.” It is far more cruel to make people live in rubble for decades.

Yet the cruelty is the point, because to the “pro-Palestinian” side of the conflict, what is best for the Palestinian people has never been the priority. Palestinians have always and forever been used as weapons against Jews. That is why there is no “pro-Palestinian” movement, there is only an anti-Israel movement. To keep these people where they are is openly stating that it is preferable to maintain that weapon than it is to ensure peaceful lives for them.

Signing a letter against allowing refugees to leave a warzone in pursuit of a better life in order to keep them as a weapon against fellow Jews in akin to signing a suicide note. The rise of attacks on Jews in the West has increased exponentially since October 7, meaning that should Gaza be allowed to re-arm and attack Israel again, this cycle will restart itself. Therefore, even when anti-semitism reverts to “normal” levels, it is only a matter of time before it rises again in solidarity with the next attack on Israel.

So why do these so-called Jewish activists sign a letter like this? Why would they openly advocate for a plan that has failed for decades? It is a simple calculation for them. They buy into the leftist philosophy of “stolen land” so deeply that they are willing to allow for murder as reparations for past sins. It doesn’t matter that the narrative is false (as the land was purchased for above market prices and developed), what matters more is the liberal guilt. They will appease that guilt with the blood of every Israeli and every Palestinian, because it allows them to look in the mirror and say they are the righteous ones.

So while they are the heroes of their own story, the fact is that these activists are truly the villains. They fight for war. They fight for destruction. All because they fight against reality. They spent hundreds of thousands of dollars to display their idiocy and bloodlust on the pages of the New York Times. To them, it was worth every penny.

* * *
Moshe Hill is a political analyst who has written for The Daily Wire, The Queens Jewish Link, and The Jewish Link of New Jersey. He is regularly featured on The Josh M Show podcast. Twitter @TheMoHill.

The views expressed in this piece are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of The Daily Wire.

​[#item_full_content]  

​[[{“value”:”

A list with over 350 names appeared in the New York Times this week to protest the proposed plan by President Donald Trump to bring peace and stability to the Palestinian people in Gaza. The ad’s brief text reads: “Trump has called for the removal of all Palestinians from Gaza. Jewish people say NO to ethnic cleansing!” The undersigned are a list of actors, leftist pulpit rabbis and cantors, and others who happily signed their names to what essentially amounts to a suicide note for the Jewish people. 

The plan that they are protesting is the proposal to relocate Palestinian refugees out of a war zone and the rubble that will take a decade to rebuild. This will allow these people to rebuild their lives, a luxury afforded to nearly every other refugee from every other conflict. The signers of this ad are against this plan because it hurts their cause, not the Palestinian one.

If these 350 names were to be polled, nearly all would claim that the future of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict would be a “two-state solution.” This policy is both outdated and completely false, a relic of a bygone diplomatic era that is antithetical to the realities of a post-October 7 world.

The “two-state solution” is spoken today only by the malicious and the ignorant. Those who speak of it either want to see Israel destroyed or they know so little about the history of the region that they are repeating what they’ve been told by those who want to see Israel destroyed.

There can be no “two-state solution” when there is already a state called Israel. You are not creating “two-states,” you are granting enough concessions and legitimacy to a group of people that have spent over 60 years conducting terrorist operations so they can themselves declare a state. They will never do so because there are not enough concessions that can be given to that terrorist entity if the state of Israel exists at all. Concessions were offered, and rejected, many times in the 1990s and 2000s.

The proof is clearly there within Gaza, as the Palestinians living there were given a de facto state in 2005. Over 10,000 Jews were forcibly removed from Gaza, from land they bought and cultivated, to make room for that state. American Jewish businessmen raised money to buy agricultural equipment from those Jews to give to the Palestinian people so they can be self-sufficient in that state. Those people destroyed that equipment, elected Hamas to govern them, and launched an 18 year terror campaign against Israel.

Now, 16 months after they launched their most successful attack, Gaza is destroyed, their leadership dead, and the people there turned from fake “refugees” into actual refugees. The Palestinians in Gaza manage to break every definition of refugee that exists. First, they were the only refugees that had their own United Nations agency dedicated to them (UNRWA). They were also the only refugees that lived in cities for four generations. Now, they are the only refugees that cannot seek refuge anywhere.

After World War Two, Jewish refugees were placed in Displaced Persons (DP) camps while they resettled. Few returned back to their homes in Eastern Europe, they either fled West to America or East to help found Israel. During the Syrian Civil War, millions of refugees went to neighboring countries. Same with Ukrainians after Russia attacked. Population movement to neighboring countries is common for war refugees, and has never been called “ethnic cleansing.” It is far more cruel to make people live in rubble for decades.

Yet the cruelty is the point, because to the “pro-Palestinian” side of the conflict, what is best for the Palestinian people has never been the priority. Palestinians have always and forever been used as weapons against Jews. That is why there is no “pro-Palestinian” movement, there is only an anti-Israel movement. To keep these people where they are is openly stating that it is preferable to maintain that weapon than it is to ensure peaceful lives for them.

Signing a letter against allowing refugees to leave a warzone in pursuit of a better life in order to keep them as a weapon against fellow Jews in akin to signing a suicide note. The rise of attacks on Jews in the West has increased exponentially since October 7, meaning that should Gaza be allowed to re-arm and attack Israel again, this cycle will restart itself. Therefore, even when anti-semitism reverts to “normal” levels, it is only a matter of time before it rises again in solidarity with the next attack on Israel.

So why do these so-called Jewish activists sign a letter like this? Why would they openly advocate for a plan that has failed for decades? It is a simple calculation for them. They buy into the leftist philosophy of “stolen land” so deeply that they are willing to allow for murder as reparations for past sins. It doesn’t matter that the narrative is false (as the land was purchased for above market prices and developed), what matters more is the liberal guilt. They will appease that guilt with the blood of every Israeli and every Palestinian, because it allows them to look in the mirror and say they are the righteous ones.

So while they are the heroes of their own story, the fact is that these activists are truly the villains. They fight for war. They fight for destruction. All because they fight against reality. They spent hundreds of thousands of dollars to display their idiocy and bloodlust on the pages of the New York Times. To them, it was worth every penny.

* * *
Moshe Hill is a political analyst who has written for The Daily Wire, The Queens Jewish Link, and The Jewish Link of New Jersey. He is regularly featured on The Josh M Show podcast. Twitter @TheMoHill.

The views expressed in this piece are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of The Daily Wire.

“}]] 

 

Sign up to receive our newsletter

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.